booksreddit.com:Precision Machine Design

Precision Machine Design

387

This book is a comprehensive engineering exploration of all the aspects of precision machine design – both component and system design considerations for precision machines. It addresses both theoretical analysis and practical implementation providing many real-world design case studies as well as numerous examples of existing components and their characteristics. Fast becoming a classic, this book includes examples of analysis techniques, along with the philosophy of the solution method. I…

More details

Most upvoted comment

How can precision be achieved starting basically from scratch, without using precisely made implements?(r/AskEngineers)

Other comments here are spot on.

The simplistic version that underlies all of them is humans are smart so they can identify a problem and approach the desired solution iteratively. This creates a feedback loop.

Before “modern” (the mid to late 1800’s onwards) machine tools, you had people making a lot of things custom every time using files to get parts to mate together. There are some exceptions to this with specific measurement and manufacturing tools that were conceived and used but they weren’t in wide spread use before the Industrial Revolution and they didn’t look as similar to today’s machines as everything after. We humans are really good at tweaking stuff slightly until it is far beyond the precision of the individual pieces itself.

Similarly, if I took any old lathe or mill, measured my part to be 0.100″ and needed it to be 0.050″, I could dial a cut in at 0.05″ and take it but depending on the quality and rigidity of the machine, workholding, bearing surfaces and tooling, I would be hard pressed to hit that 0.050″ dead on. However, I could take as many passes I wanted while remeasuring until I’m happy with the result. Cut 0.020″ off, measure again, I should have 0.030″ left but I actually have 0.027″ left. Cut again this time at 0.010″ and I should have 0.017″ left but I have 0.015″ left etc.

As others mentioned, the 3 plate method allows you to generate with time and effort, a very precisely flat surface. I could generate that surface, use it as my surface referenced plate and then hand scrape a piece to match it’s flatness and squareness to the best of my willingness to work on it. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hand_scraper if you’re unfamiliar. The craftsman inks (blues) up a reference surface, imprints the work piece by rubbing it on that surface. Only the points in contact touch. Using a scraper and some training, you can remove .0002″ with a scraper cut. Remove all of the high spots that are blue bringing the high spots closer to the average. Remark and do it again iteratively. Each time you bring your work surface closer to your reference.

The same thing was done with precision lead screws. Hand made screws were cut with primitive methods and put in early lathe like machines to cut more screws. These machines had error compensation methods built in that averaged the thread cutting across the original screw (or sometimes multiple screws) resulting in a screw that was more precise than what you started with.

For calibrating a reference surface for flatness, you can use levels or autocollimators for overall variations. The precision of your level can be increased by increasing the longitudinal radius of your glass bubble dial.

An excerpt from another post I made in /r/cnc: Some source material to consider: LINK A great site with collections of documents covering major works in the development of precision tools.

Precision Machine Design – Slocum more of a textbook on precision machine design but has tons of footnotes and talks about some of the developmental history.)

Inventing Accuracy: A Historical Sociology of Nuclear Missile Guidance talks about some of the accuracy needed in Oakridge etc to help make the atomic bomb and precision guided missiles before GPS existed even for the military. A number of military interests drove ultra precision development such as this and the large optical diamond turning maching (LODTM)

Rolling Bearings and their contribution to the progress of technology covers the history of bearings that allowed precision machinery.

Machine Tool Reconditioning is an older book and highly technical but is considered the bible for old machine tool rebuilding and goes into the processes of how one would make precision flat surfaces and check all of the geometry on their machines and fix them in a time before lasers and fancy computer controlled equipment.

Foundations of Mechanical Accuracy and the followup book Holes, Contours and Surfaces was written by Moore and his son (I believe, respectively), the first especially is considered a bible on the theory of obtaining super precision tolerances. The authors are part of Moore Tool Company which made amongst other machines Moore Jig Borers.

Mitutoyo has a pdf on the history of gauge blocks

You can further go down that rabbit hole and look at metrology books as one can achieve great tolerances by iteratively approaching a desired value and having proper metrology equipment to check your work as you go. For example, metrology standards

You can also look at old professional telescope building books and newer diy telescope making books as there’s a lot of interesting information and techniques to obtain precision optics on the order of wavelengths of light.

As someone else here mentioned: How Round Is Your Circle

I can probably dig up a lot more. I’ve spent way to much money purchasing old out of print books related to precision machinery, machining and metrology.

From the iterative process of making basic tools, you can then use those tools to make even better tools through iteration. In many ways, it’s similar to Moore’s law in the electronics world; a exponential curve where we stand on the shoulder of giants and improve upon what already exists. Many have proposed technology as a whole as just that such as Ray Kurzweil in “The Singularity is Near” etc.

Edit: Thanks for the gold!

More details about a book.

Additional Information

Subreddits

AskEngineers

Number Of Links

1

Sum Of Upvotes

112

Amazon Price

$112.0

NSFW Product

SFW

Book Binding

Paperback

Type Code

ABIS_BOOK

Book Author

Alexander H. Slocum

Book Edition

illustrated edition

Book Publisher

Society of Manufacturing

Book On Amazon

Precision Machine Design

Post Title

How can precision be achieved starting basically from scratch, without using precisely made implements?

Reddit Gold

1

More details