Book · 2014
The Troop
by Nick Cutter
Four Boy Scouts and their troop leader get stranded on an island with a starving stranger carrying an engineered parasite.
What does Reddit think of The Troop?
The most-upvoted line in this whole sample (↑1335) is a joke: someone calls The Troop "cozy" because its parasite is so cozy inside its host, then asks, deadpan, "Am I doing it right?" That's a request for cozy horror answered with the least cozy possible book, rewarded with upvotes, which tells you more about r/horrorlit's sense of humor than about the novel itself. The sincere version of that reaction sits right below it (↑131): "Was it a good book? Yes. Do I still have visceral flashbacks two years later? It gets filed alongside The Ritual and Offseason (↑74) on cabin-and-woods horror lists, camping and body horror named directly as its subgenre slot. Nobody here argues it's a weak entry. The only real argument is how much of it a reader can stomach.
Community feedback & reader fit
Themes
- · Body horror via an engineered parasite that turns its host's hunger against them
- · A Boy Scout camping trip as the setting for isolation horror
- · Filed on cabin-and-woods horror lists next to The Ritual and Offseason
- · Visceral, stomach-level horror over supernatural dread
Common praise
- + Gets recommended as 'cozy horror' by name as an inside joke that lands (↑1335), the kind of upvote count a sub only gives a joke everyone's actually in on.
- + One reader reports 'visceral flashbacks two years later' and still calls it a good book (↑131), about the strongest endorsement this genre offers.
- + Slots directly into camping and body-horror list company (↑74) without needing a separate pitch.
Common criticism
- − Every displayed excerpt treats the horror as effective rather than enjoyable, itself a warning for readers who want scares without lingering discomfort.
- − The 'cozy horror' framing (↑1335), even as a joke, only works because the book is understood as an extreme, not a middle-of-the-road pick. That's a narrow lane to occupy.
Who it's for
Bring a strong stomach, not a taste for slow-burn dread, because the parasite premise here sits closer to body horror than atmosphere. If someone in r/horrorlit hands you this as a joke answer to a 'cozy horror' request, that's the sub's actual opinion of the book, not just a bit. Camping-horror completionists should read it next to The Ritual and Offseason, per the list where it already lives.
Mentions over time
Top subreddits
Which Reddit comments matter for The Troop?
The most relevant excerpts across the subreddits where this book is mentioned — opinionated, argued takes first, then top-upvoted mentions. Click through to read the full thread.
“The troop by Nick cutter. Was it a good book? Yes. Do I have still have visceral flashbacks two years later? Also yes. At least I learned that parasitic horror will really affect me
“I think the Troop by Nick Cutter is a good read. And as already suggested the Infected Trilogy by Scott Sigler
“Not ghosts, but I personally found Nick Cutter's "The Troop" pretty scary. Really body horror, and some of the passages felt awful while reading. More paranormally minded would be like Paul Tremblay's "Head Full of Ghosts" or "Cabin at the End of the World". I personally like the tension of not kn…
“I just finished up The Troop by Nick Cutter and I thought it was absolutely disgusting and good read if thats your thing! It's a bit like The Thing mixed with Lord of the Flies. Super gross, recommend it.
“Not traditional horror, but I’m Thinking of Ending Things by Ian Reid is terrifying in a bizarre, psychological way. The Troop by Nick Cutter is a fantastic horror that I enjoyed greatly. The Terror by Dan Simmons is horrifying and very well written, lots of things to be afraid of here - both the ex…
“The Hunger - Alma Katsu What a s*** way to write about historical figures. Keseberg sued and won for a lesser defamation than this godawful book. The Troop - Nick Cutter I get it, it had potential. I get what people like about it, but Eef wasn't believable, Shelly was especially not believable, a…
“I got halfway through The Troop by Nick Cutter before I stopped and wondered if I really wanted to ever read horror again. It was so disgusting that I get upset when I think about it
“For me, it has to be The Troop by Nick Cutter. God what a disturbing book. It was fantastic but goodness it was so unsettling.
“Can’t get into Grady Hendrix. I’ve read two of his books and found them so boring. Almost to the point of “I could have done a better job” which I know I can’t but I meant I’ve read so much better. I felt the same about Cutter’s The Troop and Holden’s Ararat.
“Check out The Troop by Nick Cutter, spooky as hell and not a long one.
“I never touched Girl Next Door because knowing the true story it's based on was enough for me. I didnt like the idea of reading a fictionalized take on a very real, very f***** up thing that actually happened to a young girl. I really enjoyed The Troop by Nick Cutter overall, but I had to skip thro…
“I’ve don’t mind most horror and enjoyed Exquisite Corpse and The Troop and survived American Psycho with some judicious skipping but I didn’t make it through a tiktok review of Cows that described the playground in PG13 language.
“To me he’s just so clearly trying to imitate Stephen King. The whole time I was reading The Troop I was convinced Nick Cutter was just a new pseudonym of Joe Hill’s
“Reading The Troop by Nick Cutter while sitting by a campfire in the middle of the woods was pretty creepy.
“The Troop by Nick Cutter - one of the few books to genuinely make me sick to my stomach
Convinced? Pick up The Troop
What else does r/horrorlit read?
Other books mentioned in the same sub, ranked. Shared-sub overlap with this title breaks ties.
The Troop — frequently asked
Is The Troop actually cozy horror, or is that a joke?+
It's a joke, and a pointed one. The top-upvoted comment on record (↑1335) calls it cozy specifically because the parasite is comfortable inside its host, then asks 'Am I doing it right?' That's r/horrorlit using the book as the deliberately wrong answer to a cozy-horror request, not a genuine genre classification.
How intense is The Troop compared to other horror novels on Reddit?+
On the intense end, per the one reader who describes the aftermath directly: 'Do I still have visceral flashbacks two years later? Also yes' (↑131), while still calling it a good book. That combination, lasting discomfort plus a clear recommendation, is the strongest signal in this sample.
What should I read after The Troop if I want more camping or body horror?+
A r/horrorlit list (↑74) groups it with The Ritual, The Watchers, and Offseason under woodsy, camping-adjacent horror, distinguishing The Troop's body-horror angle from the more supernatural bent of the others. No excerpt ranks them; they're presented as a matched set by setting.