Book · 1880
The Brothers Karamazov
by Fyodor Dostoevsky
Three brothers, a murdered father, and a murder trial become the frame Dostoevsky uses to argue about God, guilt, and free will for nearly a thousand pages.
What does Reddit think of The Brothers Karamazov?
Nothing here disagrees, which for a nineteenth-century Russian novel this long is itself worth noting. r/suggestmeabook carries almost the entire signal: one commenter says flatly, 'I still think about it and it's been over 10 years.' Another singles out Alyosha specifically, 'one of my all time favorite characters,' while granting that all three brothers are 'fascinating and complex.' It gets called Dostoevsky's magnum opus outright, with the added framing that it's 'a murder mystery plus philosophy,' the kind of pitch that undersells how long the book takes to pay off. That payoff isn't free: one reader reports it 'had my head spinning for like two weeks,' offered as praise, not complaint. It's also the default second stop after Crime and Punishment for anyone working through Dostoevsky's catalogue. Nobody hedges. Nobody in this sample is neutral, either.
Community feedback & reader fit
Themes
- · Long-tail memorability, cited as unforgettable a decade later
- · Alyosha singled out among the three brothers as the standout
- · Framed as a murder mystery wrapped around philosophy
- · The standard second stop in a Dostoevsky reading order, after Crime and Punishment
Common praise
- + One reader says flatly, 'I still think about it and it's been over 10 years,' no further justification offered (↑322).
- + Another names Alyosha specifically as 'one of my all time favorite characters,' out of three brothers all called fascinating (↑290).
- + It gets called Dostoevsky's magnum opus outright, described as 'a murder mystery plus philosophy' in the same breath (↑239).
Common criticism
- − One reader admits it 'had my head spinning for like two weeks,' meant as praise here, but a fair warning about the difficulty either way (↑236).
- − Every displayed excerpt treats it as required reading within Dostoevsky's catalogue, so the sample offers no counterweight if you're deciding whether to skip it.
Who it's for
Coming off Crime and Punishment and looking for the next stop? One commenter routes you straight here and calls it the magnum opus (↑239). Want a plot hook before you commit to the philosophy? It's pitched as 'a murder mystery plus philosophy' in that same reply. Block out real time, one reader's head was 'spinning for like two weeks' getting through it (↑236), so don't expect a weekend read. And if you're choosing a favorite brother going in, Alyosha's already got at least one vote locked in (↑290).
Mentions over time
Which Reddit comments matter for The Brothers Karamazov?
The most relevant excerpts across the subreddits where this book is mentioned — opinionated, argued takes first, then top-upvoted mentions. Click through to read the full thread.
“The Brothers Karamazov. I still think about it and it's been over 10 years.
“The Brothers Karamazov by Dostoyevsky- all the brothers are fascinating and complex, but Alyosha remains one of my all time favorite characters
“Read the other works of Dostoevsky. The Brothers Karamazov is his magnum opus. That too is a murder mystery plus philosophy.
“There's always The Brothers Karamazov. Great read, had my head spinning for like two weeks.
“Any Dostoyevsky, but especially Crime and Punishment and Brothers Karamazov. The best writer I have come across so far.
“The Brothers Karamazov by Fyodor Dostoevsky! This book is inexhaustible in that its’ philosophical and psychological depth knows no bounds. This book touches on just about every point of human emotions. This book may seem intimidating at first, but I assure you that anyone who completes the novel wi…
“I'll let Vonnegut do it for me: "There is one book, that can teach you everything you need to know about life... it's The Brothers Karamazov by Fyodor Dostoevsky."
“I highly recommend Brothers Karamazov by Dostoevsky. This book changed my life for the better. Made me much more open to other point of views.
“Crime and Punishment & The Brothers Karamazov by Dostoevsky; Both books have deep and philosophical dialogs that will stay with you forever. Also the characters are so well written you will feel as if you know them personally.
“{{The Brothers Karamazov}} is probably the most soul heavy book out there.
“The Brothers Karamazov. I've read it six times and every time it leaves me completely wrecked mentally and spiritually and I never regret it. It's like chemotherapy for my soul - I want to vomit and all my hair is going to fall out but the cancer in my heart is healed.
“The Death of Ivan Ilyich if he wants some solidarity while he sickens and passes away. The Brothers Karamazov is also a must-read-before-you-die, especially in times like his, but it does have a Russian Orthodox bent (although I think it's a universal book).
“I‘m bringing *Blood Meridian* or good old *Brothers Karamazov*
“*The Brothers Karamazov* and *Notes from Underground* also by Fyodor Dostoevsky are worth checking out too.
“The first time I read The Brothers Karamazov I was absolutely floored by Dostoyevsky’s dialogues and allegorical story telling. Never have I read a book that delved more into the hidden depths of human truth than that one. It remains one the best books I’ve ever read.
Convinced? Pick up The Brothers Karamazov
Readers also mention
Books that share discussion threads with The Brothers Karamazov — counted from the comments, not curated.
Guides featuring The Brothers Karamazov
Ranked best-of lists and editorial guides where this book's tracked mentions place it.
The Brothers Karamazov — frequently asked
Is The Brothers Karamazov worth the time investment?+
Reddit's displayed answer here is yes, emphatically. One r/suggestmeabook comment (↑322) says 'I still think about it and it's been over 10 years.' Another calls it Dostoevsky's magnum opus outright (↑239). Nothing in the sample argues the opposite.
Who is the best character in The Brothers Karamazov, according to Reddit?+
Alyosha, per one commenter who calls him 'one of my all time favorite characters,' while still granting that all three brothers are 'fascinating and complex' (↑290). That's the only displayed excerpt to single out a specific brother.
Should I read Crime and Punishment or The Brothers Karamazov first?+
Crime and Punishment, based on how one r/suggestmeabook comment frames it: 'Read the other works of Dostoevsky. The Brothers Karamazov is his magnum opus' (↑239), implying a payoff read, not a starting point. A separate comment (↑227) recommends 'especially Crime and Punishment and Brothers Karamazov' together, in that order.
Is The Brothers Karamazov actually a murder mystery?+
Partly, per one description: it's 'a murder mystery plus philosophy' (↑239). Don't expect a conventional mystery pace though, one reader reports it 'had my head spinning for like two weeks' getting through it (↑236).