Book · 2018
The Poppy War
by R. F. Kuang
A dark-skinned war orphan tests into an elite military academy, discovers she can channel a fire god, and burns her way toward genocide.
What does Reddit think of The Poppy War?
The split runs between subreddits as much as within any one of them. r/suggestmeabook's scored comments run warm, calling it "light retaliatory genocide" territory and pitching it as "Game of Thrones meets Avatar: The Last Airbender," a female lead's rise from outsider to power. r/Fantasy runs the other direction, into genuinely critical territory. An ↑632 comment recalls being sold on a "gut-wrenching, dark book" and instead getting "a played straight school story for like 200 pages." An ↑1315 comment draws the same line drawn against Children of Blood and Bone, citing reviews that say it "reads like someone who poorly understands" the culture it draws on. Another, ↑385, calls its relationship to history "uncanny" rather than grounded. An ↑390 comment names the gap directly: years after George R. R. Martin helped drive the launch buzz, the book "doesn't actually get tons of praise in this sub" anymore, saddled with "problems that don't match the hype it received."
Community feedback & reader fit
Themes
- · Game of Thrones meets Avatar comparison
- · cultural-authenticity backlash
- · hype-versus-reception gap
- · slow-burn descent into atrocity
Common praise
- + An ↑488 r/suggestmeabook commenter admits the retaliatory-genocide plotline made them question their own actual morals.
- + r/suggestmeabook keeps reaching for the same shorthand, Game of Thrones meets Avatar: The Last Airbender, and readers keep nodding along.
- + Its early buzz got real traction, per an ↑477 comment noting George R. R. Martin was among the names talking it up on release.
Common criticism
- − An ↑632 r/Fantasy commenter says it was pitched as gut-wrenching and dark, then delivered 'a played straight school story for like 200 pages.'
- − An ↑1315 r/Fantasy comment draws a direct line to the Children of Blood and Bone backlash, pointing at reviews calling the cultural research shallow.
- − An ↑385 r/Fantasy comment says the book sits in an 'uncanny valley' relationship with the history it borrows from, rather than a grounded one.
- − An ↑390 comment says the praise has cooled inside r/Fantasy itself, years after the initial hype outran what the book actually delivers.
Who it's for
Want grimdark built on real 20th-century atrocity instead of medieval Europe? That's the pitch r/suggestmeabook keeps making, usually with the Game of Thrones/Avatar comparison attached. Expect a slow fuse, though. The ↑632 complaint about 200 pages of school-story setup before anything dark happens is a real pacing tax, not a one-off gripe. Care a lot about historical and cultural grounding holding up to scrutiny? Read r/Fantasy's harsher commenters first, including the direct comparison to the Children of Blood and Bone backlash. Came in chasing the George R. R. Martin-era hype? Know that r/Fantasy regulars themselves say that enthusiasm has cooled.
Mentions over time
Top subreddits
Which Reddit comments matter for The Poppy War?
The most relevant excerpts across the subreddits where this book is mentioned — opinionated, argued takes first, then top-upvoted mentions. Click through to read the full thread.
“Not gonna lie I was kinda pissed when everyone recommended Poppy War to me as a really gut wrenching, dark book, and then it's just a played straight school story for like 200 pages lmao
“The Poppy War, by R.F. Kuang. I usually end up looking down my nose at characters who are very obviously making decisions that are leading them down such a dark path, but in this case I found myself genuinely questioning my own actual morals. If you're down for some light retaliatory genocide, The…
“>The result is unimaginative, **uncanny** I have said this before in this reddit, that The Poppy War somehow occupies an uncanny valley relationship with history. Much of Fantasy is heavily inspired by either history or the mythology of different cultures, one can view a sort of continium of how mu…
“The Poppy War. Surprised I don't see this. Recommended many times by many people. Finished the first book and dropped the second. Just no.
“Just one, The Poppy War. Not because of explicitly depicted horrors of mass torture and genocide that most readers were not prepared for in an otherwise mostly tame novel, but because it's just poorly written.
“I really disliked the Sarah J Maas books I've read. Maybe more controversially, I hated The Poppy War. I still recommend it to others because I get my experience was in the minority. I also loved Babel and would broadly recommend RF Kuang. But The Poppy War was paced in such a bizarre way and unti…
“Amazed no one else has mentioned this series… but I suppose that’s the point of this prompt. The Poppy War trilogy One of the worst book series I’ve ever read. I’m convinced that everyone mislabels these books as adult because of their content— they are not books for adults; they are young adult f…
“Short answer: no. Not only because Rin is not intended to be a likeable character, but also because character writing is not one of RF Kuang's strengths as an author. *The Poppy War* has a cool premise ("what if Mao were a woman?" and also "how does someone like Mao become Mao?") with some didactic…
“The poppy war is just too depressing for me.
“I only read the first Poppy War book, but they're definitely not universally loved like you think, particularly on this sub. It's got major issues, massive change in vibe, some terrible characters and has a bit of an identity crisis. That's why I didn't pick up the second.
“Poppy War/Traitor Baru Slogged through like 95% of poppy War and finally had to put it down. Writing style/pose really got to me.
“Hands down The Poppy War. It was talked up for the better part of two years. The tonal shift made it feel like two books crammed together.
“Poppy war is the best example. I didnt hate the Wheel of Time.. but I feel especially under Robert Jordan Im just reading page after page of characters refusing to communicate normally, tugging their braids and crossing their arms under their breasts.
“To me it’s not specifically the dialogue but that not a single character except Robin is anything more than a caricature and they have no life/personality outside the colonialism is bad themes, which in fact would have been stronger if we saw real people living in this (well-built) world rather than…
“Yes, it's not a particularly sophisticated view of colonialism or racism. To be fair, I thought the same could be said for her depiction of violence and genocide in Poppy War. Kuang is a very promising writer, particularly given how young she is, but I'm confused by the accolades she's earning. Th…
Convinced? Pick up The Poppy War
Readers also mention
All books like The Poppy War →Books that share discussion threads with The Poppy War — counted from the comments, not curated.
The Poppy War — frequently asked
Is The Poppy War as dark as its reputation suggests?+
Eventually, but not immediately. An ↑632 r/Fantasy comment complains it was sold as gut-wrenching and dark, then reads as 'a played straight school story for like 200 pages' before anything happens. Once it turns, an ↑488 r/suggestmeabook comment says the retaliatory-genocide arc genuinely shook their own sense of morality.
Is The Poppy War historically or culturally accurate?+
Contested. An ↑1315 r/Fantasy comment compares the criticism to the backlash against Children of Blood and Bone, citing reviews that call the cultural grounding shallow. A separate ↑385 comment goes further, describing the book's relationship to the history it draws on as 'uncanny' rather than solid.
Is The Poppy War overhyped?+
r/Fantasy itself says the hype has outlasted the enthusiasm. An ↑390 comment notes the book doesn't get much praise in the sub anymore and carries 'problems that don't match the hype it received,' years after launch buzz that included George R. R. Martin talking it up, per an ↑477 comment.
Is The Poppy War similar to Game of Thrones and Avatar: The Last Airbender?+
That's the recurring r/suggestmeabook comparison. An ↑397 comment describes it as 'Game of Thrones meets Avatar the Last Airbender,' built on Asian mythology instead of European settings, following a female lead's rise from outsider status, though the resemblance is a pitch, not a guarantee of tone.